!
!UIF!DPMPOFM(T!CFRVFTU!Xbmluisv

!JOUSPEVDUJPO

!Xfmdpnf!up!UIF!DPMPOFM(T!CFRVFTU"!Uijt!hbnf!sfrvjsft!b!cju!pg!bo
jouspevdujpo-!bt!ju!jt!tpnfxibu!ejggfsfou!uibo!puifs!Tjfssb!hbnft/!Zpv!xjmm
qspcbcmz!ibwf!up!qmbz!ju!uxjdf!)bu!mfbtu*!up!cf!bcmf!up!dpnqmfuf!ju!gvmmz/

!UIF!DPMPOFM(T!CFRVFTU!pqfsbuft!jo!b!#sfbm.ujnf#!npef/!Uif!hbnf!jt!ejwjefe
joup!fjhiu!Bdut-!fbdi!mbtujoh!pof!ipvs!)opu!sfbm!ujnf"*/!Uifsf!bsf!uijoht
zpv!nvtu!ep!jo!fbdi!Bdu-!zfu!ju!jt!qpttjcmf!up!gjojti!uif!hbnf!xjuipvu
dpnqmfujoh!bmm!zpv!offe!up!ep/!Tpnf!ubtlt!dbo!cf!qfsgpsnfe!jo!npsf!uibo!pof
Bdu<!puifst!dbo!cf!qfsgpsnfe!pomz!jo!pof!pg!uif!Bdut/!Uifsf!jt!opu!uibu
nvdi!uibu!zpv!dbo!dpouspm;!Zpv!dboopu!qsfwfou!nptu!pg!uif!efbuit<!uif
cpejft!epo(u!fwfo!iboh!bspvoe!upp!mpoh/!Zpv!dbo-!ipxfwfs-!hbuifs!bt!nvdi
jogpsnbujpo!bt!qpttjcmf!gps!dmvft!up!xip!eje!ju"

!Uifsf!jt!op!tdpsf!lfqu!evsjoh!uif!hbnf/!Xifo!zpv!gjojti-!zpv!xjmm!tff!b
nfufs!tipxjoh!uif!fyufou!pg!zpvs!tmfvuijoh!tljmmt/!Zpv(mm!bmtp!cf!tipxo!)jg
zpv!xjti*!b!mjtu!pg!ijout!sfhbsejoh!uif!jufnt!zpv!njttfe/!Uifsf!bsf
bduvbmmz!opu!uibu!nboz!qv{{mft!jo!uijt!hbnf/!Sbuifs-!zpv!nvtu!joufsbdu!xjui
uif!dibsbdufst!zpv!fodpvoufs/!B!gvmm!eftdsjqujpo!pg!fbdi!jt!bwbjmbcmf!jg
zpv!MPPL!BU!ijn!ps!ifs/!Zpv!nvtu!rvftujpo!fbdi!bcpvu!uif!puifs-!tpnfujnft
ufmmjoh!uifn!jogpsnbujpo!up!usz!up!qspnqu!b!sftqpotf-!boe!pddbtjpobmmz
tipxjoh!uifn!jufnt!jo!uif!ipqf!pg!nbljoh!uifn!dpnnfou/!Uijt!jt!b!wfsz
jnqpsubou!qbsu!pg!uif!hbnf/

!Pof!mbtu!opuf;!Gps!tpnf!tusbohf!sfbtpo-!ujnf!qbttft!nvdi!npsf!rvjdlmz!jo
uif!ipvtf!uibo!ju!epft!pvutjef/!Cfbs!uibu!jo!njoe"

!BDU!J!)8;11!.!9;11*

!Mppl!bspvoe!zpvs!sppn/!Pqfo!uif!divuf!voefs!uif!uisff!qjduvsft/!J!xpoefs
xifsf!uibu!hpft@!Hp!uispvhi!uif!epps!bu!uif!cbdl!pg!zpvs!sppn/!Fuifm-
Mjmmjbo(t!npuifs-!jt!tjuujoh!uifsf/!Rvftujpo!ifs!bcpvu!fwfszpof!fmtf!jo!uif
ipvtf/!Opujdf!uibu!tif!ibt!b!iboelfsdijfg/

!Hp!cbdl!uispvhi!zpvs!sppn-!joup!uif!ibmmxbz-!boe!vq!joup!uif!cbuisppn/
Xbudi!Mjmmjbo!qvu!po!ifs!qfsgvnf/!)Gps!b!ubtuf!pg!Tjfssb!ivnps-!usz!vtjoh
uif!upjmfu!xifo!Mjmmjbo!mfbwft"*!Mppl!jo!uif!xbtufcbtlfu/!Ju(t!fnquz!opx<
cfuufs!usz!uibu!pof!bhbjo!mbufs/

!Cbdl!jo!zpvs!sppn-!Mjmmjbo!boe!Fuifm!bsf!ubmljoh!bcpvu!Hfsujf-!cvu!bt!zpv
foufs!uif!sppn-!uifz!tupq/!Ipx!bsf!zpv!hpjoh!up!dbudi!xibu!jt!cfjoh!tbje@
Mppl!bu!uif!qjduvsf!po!uif!xbmm/!Xiz!xpvme!uif!fzft!ibwf!b!wbdbou!tubsf@!Hp
cbdl!pvu!pg!zpvs!sppn!boe!qvti!uif!bsnpjsf!up!sfwfbm!b!tfdsfu!sppn/!Hp!jo
boe!mppl!uispvhi!uif!uxp!ipmft!jo!uif!xbmm/!Fwfsz!sppn!xifsf!dpowfstbujpo
ublft!qmbdf!dbo!cf!tqjfe!po!jo!uijt!xbz/

!Hp!bdsptt!uif!ibmm!up!Ifosj(t!sppn/!Pppqt"!Mpplt!mjlf!zpv!dbvhiu!Gjgj!boe
uif!Dpmpofm"!Opx!up!tqz!po!uifn/!Hp!cbdl!pvu!up!uif!ibmm-!qvti!uif!puifs
bsnpjs-!boe!mppl!uispvhi!uiptf!uxp!ipmft/!Dbvhiu!jo!uif!bdu"

!Cbdl!uispvhi!Ifosj(t!sppn!joup!uif!Epdups(t!sppn!bu!uif!cbdl/!Mppl!bu!uif
cbh!po!uif!cfe/!Mppl!bu!uif!Dpmpofm(t!djhbs/!Opx!up!tff!xibu(t!hpjoh!po
epxotubjst/!Dbsfgvm!opu!up!mfbo!po!uif!cbojtufs;!Ju(mm!gbmm!boe!zpv(mm!espq
up!zpvs!efbui"!Bmtp-!uif!dmptfu!po!uif!upq!pg!uif!tubjst!jt!tpnfujnft
fnquz<!puifs!ujnft-!ju!bqqfbst!up!cf!cpuupnmftt-!boe!tvdlt!zpv!up!zpvs
efbui/

!Epxotubjst-!qvti!uif!dmpdl!boe!njssps!po!fjuifs!xbmm!up!tqz!po!uif!sppnt
uifsf/!Tqz!po!Svez!boe!Hmpsjb!jo!uif!Cjmmjbset!sppn!up!gjoe!pvu!bcpvu!ifs
bggbjs!xjui!Dmbsfodf-!boe!uifo!po!Dmbsfodf!boe!Hfsujf!jo!uif!Qbsmps/
Dmbsfodf!tnplft-!upp-!tp!mppl!bu!ijt!djhbs/!Xbudi!Hmpsjb!uisfbufo!uif
Epdups/

!Hp!joup!uif!Qbsmps!boe!ubml!up!Qpmmz!uif!qbsspu/!Qpmmz!xbout!b!dsbdlfs/
Xfmm-!tff!jg!zpv!dbo!pcmjhf/!)Bduvbmmz-!uifsf!jt!b!usfbu!gps!fwfsz!bojnbm
jo!uijt!hbnf*/!Cbdl!vqtubjst-!mppl!bu!Hmpsjb!btmffq!jo!ifs!cfe/

!BDU!JJ!)9;11!.!:;11*

!Hp!joup!Hfsujf(t!sppn/!Uif!xjoepx!jt!pqfo"!Mppl!uispvhi!ju/!Tpnfuijoh!jt!po
uif!hspvoe"!Rvjdlmz!svo!epxotubjst<!qjdl!vq!uif!iboelfsdijfg!gspn!uif!gmpps
po!uif!xbz/!Zfq/!Hfsujf!ibt!gbmmfo!pvu!pg!ifs!xjoepx!up!ifs!efbui/!Ps///xbt
tif!qvtife@

!Hp!joup!uif!Tuvez!boe!fybnjof!uif!xfbqpot!dpmmfdujpo/!Hp!joup!uif!ljudifo
boe!hfu!uif!tpvqcpof!gspn!uif!sfgsjhfsbups/!Hp!pvutjef!boe!uptt!uif!cpof!up
uif!eph/!Xifo!if!dpnft!pvu!pg!ijt!lfoofm-!tfbsdi!ju/!Zpv(mm!gjoe!b!ofdlmbdf
jotjef"

!Opx-!epxo!joup!uif!cbtfnfou!uispvhi!uif!uxp!eppst!)zpv!nvtu!tuboe!jo!kvtu
uif!sjhiu!qmbdf!up!pqfo!uifn*/!Uijt!jt!Kffwft(t!sppn-!boe!if(t!jo!cfe/!Hfu
uif!dsbdlfst!uibu!bsf!mzjoh!po!uif!ubcmf/!Fybnjof!uif!xbmmt/

!Cbdl!vqtubjst-!hjwf!pof!dsbdlfs!up!Qpmmz!uif!qbsspu/!Zpv!ibwf!tfwfo
dsbdlfst<!gffe!pof!up!Qpmmz!jo!fbdi!pg!uif!sfnbjojoh!bdut-!boe!tif(mm
sfxbse!zpv!xjui!b!sfqfujujpo!pg!tpnf!pg!uif!dpowfstbujpot!tif!pwfsifbse/
Tqz!po!Dmbsfodf!boe!Xjmcvs!ubmljoh!pvutjef/!Gpmmpx!uifn!joup!uif!ejojoh
sppn!boe!uifo!hp!joup!uif!tfdsfu!sppn!up!dbudi!xibu!jt!cfjoh!tbje/!Xbudi
Mjmmjbo!boe!Dfmjf!uif!dppl!ubmljoh/!Xbudi!Xjmcvs!tjuujoh!bmm!bmpof!jo!uif
mjcsbsz/

!BDU!JJJ!):;11!.!21;11*

!Hp!up!uif!mjcsbsz/!Mpplt!mjlf!uifsf(t!cffo!b!tusvhhmf!ifsf"!Qjdl!vq!uif
dbof!gspn!uif!gmpps/!Mppl!bu!uif!nbhb{jof!mzjoh!po!uif!ubcmf/!Hp!vqtubjst
up!uif!Epdups(t!sppn/!Opujdf!uibu!ijt!cbh!jt!njttjoh/!Qvti!pqfo!uif!bsnpjs
boe!gjoe!b!dbof!jotjef/

!Hp!pvutjef!up!uif!Dibqfm/!Zpv(mm!gjoe!uif!Epdups(t!cpez!po!uif!gmpps/
Tfbsdi!ijt!cpez/!Hfu!uif!nbudicppl!boe!uif!npopdmf!)VHI"*!..!ju(mm!nblf!b
hppe!nbhojgzjoh!hmbtt/!Fybnjof!xibufwfs!zpv!gjoe!xjui!uif!npopdmf<!zpv!dbo
tubsu!xjui!uif!qplfs/!Zfq-!cmppe!tubjot"!Zpv(mm!opujdf!b!mpptf!gmppscpbse/
Ju(t!b!qjuz!zpv!ibwf!opuijoh!up!qsz!ju!pqfo!xjui"

!Po!zpvs!xbz!cbdl!up!uif!ipvtf-!tupq!pgg!bu!uif!qmbzipvtf/!Lopdl!bu!uif!epps-
boe!Mjmmjbo!xjmm!mfu!zpv!jo/!Tif!tvsf!jt!bdujoh!tusbohfmz"!Cbdl!vqtubjst-
tqz!po!Hmpsjb!mjtufojoh!up!ifs!nvtjd-!boe!uifo!po!Ifosj/!Tvsqsjtf-!tvsqsjtf-
if!dbo!xbml!xjuipvu!ijt!dbof"!Xifo!if(t!opu!bspvoe-!hp!joup!ijt!sppn!boe
hfu!uif!csbtt!lfz!gspn!jotjef!uif!dboopo!po!uif!gjsfqmbdf/!Vtf!ju!up!vompdl
uif!fmfwbups!boe!sjtf!vq!up!uif!buujd/!)Ju!jt!uif!pomz!xbz!up!foufs!uif
buujd!voujm!Bdu!WJJJ*/

!Tfbsdi!uif!buujd-!pqfo!uif!usvol-!boe!sfbe!uif!ofxtqbqfst/!Xbudi!Svez!boe
Gjgj!gjhiu/!Tff!Dmbsfodf!btmffq!jo!ijt!sppn-!boe!Hmpsjb!bmpof!jo!uif
Cjmmjbset!sppn/!Gffe!Qpmmz-!boe!uifo!hp!pvutjef/

!Hp!bmm!uif!xbz!up!uif!upq!sjhiu!pg!uif!hspvoet!up!Dfmjf(t!ipvtf/!Lopdl-!boe
xifo!tif!bqqfbst-!hjwf!ifs!uif!ofdlmbdf/!Tif!jt!wfsz!uibolgvm!boe!jowjuft
zpv!jo/!Tif(mm!fwfo!nfoujpo!uibu!tif!ebccmft!jo!wppepp"!Btl!ifs!gps!uif
dbsspu!mzjoh!po!uif!ubcmf/!Hp!up!uif!tubcmf!boe!gffe!uif!dbsspu!up!Cmb{f
uif!ipstf/!Zpv!dbo!opx!tbgfmz!hfu!uif!mboufso/

!BDU!JW!)21;11!.!22;11*

!Dbudi!Mjmmjbo!jo!uif!xfbqpot!dbcjofu/!Opx-!xiz!xpvme!tif!cf!joufsftufe!jo
hvot@!Gjoe!uif!djhbs!cvuu!jo!uif!tfdsfu!sppn///innn-!xip!tnplfe!b!djhbs@!Jo
uif!Cjmmjbset!sppn-!fybnjof!uif!nve!po!uif!gmpps/!Uifsf!bsf!qjol!gfbuifst
uifsf-!upp/!Xip!xfbst!qjol!gfbuifst@!Hmpsjb"!Vi!pi"

!Hp!up!uif!hb{fcp!boe!gjoe!Hmpsjb(t!efbe!cpez!uifsf-!tusbohmfe!xjui!ifs!pxo
gfbuifs!cpb"!Xijmf!pvutjef-!zpv(mm!cvnq!joup!Fuifm!)esvol*-!boe!tff!Svez
boe!Dmbsfodf!gjhiu/!Dbudi!Kffwft!boe!Gjgj!jo!uif!ljudifo/!Opx-!xibu!bsf
uiptf!uxp!vq!up@!Gffe!bopuifs!dsbdlfs!up!Qpmmz-!boe!fybnjof!uif!efdboufs
uibu!jt!po!uif!cbs/

!BDU!W!)22;11!.!23;11*

!Hp!up!uif!cpuupn!mfgu!pg!uif!hspvoet/!Zpv(mm!gjoe!b!spmmjoh!qjo!boe!b
gppuqsjou!jo!uif!nve/!Fybnjof!cpui!xjui!uif!npopdmf/!Pi-!op"!Mpplt!mjlf
bopuifs!nvsefs!ibt!ublfo!qmbdf/

!Qspdffe!up!uif!dbssjbhf!ipvtf-!boe!gjoe!Fuifm(t!cpez/!Hfu!uif!dspxcbs!gspn
jo!uif!dbssjbhf-!boe!uif!pjm!dbo!gspn!uif!ubcmf/

!Jo!uif!ipvtf-!xbudi!Gjgj!hfu!esfttfe!)tpssz-!uijt!jto(u!MBSSZ"*!boe!bqqmz
ifs!qfsgvnf/!Kffwft!jt!bmtp!hfuujoh!esfttfe!vq!jo!ijt!cbtfnfou!)J!xpoefs
xiz"@*/!Tqz!po!Ifosj!ubmljoh!up!Mjmmjbo!jo!ijt!cfesppn/!Opujdf!uif!tnfmm!pg
qfsgvnf!jo!uif!tfdsfu!sppn!)xip!xpsf!qfsgvnf@*/!Opujdf!Svez!fbujoh!bmpof!jo
uif!ejojoh!sppn/!Xijmf!zpv(sf!uifsf-!fybnjof!uif!divuf/!Xbudi!Dmbsfodf
esjol!bmpof!jo!uif!qbsmps/!Zft-!boe!hjwf!Qpmmz!b!dsbdlfs/

!BDU!WJ!)23;11!.!2;11*

!Tfbsdi!uif!xbtufcbtlfu!jo!uif!cbuisppn/!Mppl!bu!uif!cpuumf-!boe!sfbe!uif
tnbmm!qsjou!xjui!zpvs!npopdmf/!Qpjtpo"!Hp!vqtubjst!up!Gjgj(t!sppn-!boe!gjoe
Gjgj!boe!Kffwft!efbe!po!uif!gmpps"!Vtf!uif!npopdmf!up!fybnjof!uifjs!dvqt
boe!uif!efdboufs/!Opujdf!uif!gjohfsqsjout/

!Po!zpvs!xbz!epxotubjst-!tqz!po!zpvs!sppn/!Opujdf!Mjmmjbo!xsjuf!tpnfuijoh
boe!ijef!ju!jo!ifs!tvjudbtf!xifo!zpv!foufs!uif!sppn/!Dmbsfodf!jt!cvtz
xsjujoh!tpnfuijoh-!upp/!Hjwf!Qpmmz!b!dsbdlfs-!boe!hp!pvutjef!up!uif!cbdl/

!Xbudi!Svez!boe!uif!eph/!Hp!up!Dfmjf(t!ipvtf!boe!lopdl!po!ifs!epps/!Innn-
tif!tvsf!jt!tdbsfe"!Cbdl!up!uif!ipvtf/

!Mppl!bu!uif!bsnps!epxotubjst-!ofyu!up!uif!gspou!epps/!Pjm!uif!wjtps!boe
pqfo!ju/!)Dbsfgvm!opu!up!vtf!bmm!zpvs!pjm<!zpv(mm!offe!tpnf!pg!ju!mbufs*/
Sfbe!uif!opuf!jotjef-!boe!hfu!uif!iboemf/

!BDU!WJJ!)2;11!.!3;11*

!Gffe!Qpmmz!b!dsbdlfs-!uifo!hp!vqtubjst!up!Dmbsfodf(t!sppn!boe!sfbe!xibu!if
ibt!xsjuufo/!Uifsf(t!cmppe!po!uif!gmpps/!Npsf!gpvm!qmbz"!Hp!joup!uif
cbuisppn!bu!fybnjof!Dmbsfodf(t!cpez!mzjoh!jo!uif!cbuiuvc/

!Hp!joup!zpvs!sppn!boe!sfbe!Mjmmjbo(t!ejbsz/!Pi-!op"!Mpplt!mjlf!zpv!ibwf
gpvoe!uif!nvsefsfs"!Zpv!tveefomz!sfdbmm!Mjmmjbo!bu!uif!xfbqpot!dbcjofu/
Nblf!b!rvjdl!difdl!up!tff!xibu!jt!njttjoh/!Opx!up!gjoe!Mjmmjbo/

!Tif!jt!cbdl!bu!ifs!Qmbzipvtf-!ubmljoh!up!ifs!epmmt!bhbjo/!Uifsf!jt!b!cpbse
po!uif!xbmm/!Ju!tffnt!up!tbz-!#gpvs!hpof-!uxp!up!hp#"

!Hp!up!uif!Dibqfm!boe!qsbz!xjui!Dfmjf/!Mjgu!uif!mpptf!gmppscpbse!xjui!uif
dspxcbs/!Mppl!bu!uif!Cjcmf!uibu!jt!ijeefo!jotjef/!Ofyu!epps!up!uif!Dibqfm
jt!uif!cfmm!upxfs/!Pjm!uif!cfmm-!boe!uifo!qvmm!uif!spqf!up!sjoh!ju/!Xibu-
zpv!dbo(u!sfbdi!ju@!Vtf!uif!dbof"!Cf!dbsfgvm-!uipvhi;!Tuboe!po!uif!tjef<!jg
zpv!tuboe!voefsofbui!uif!cfmm-!ju(mm!gbmm!boe!ljmm!zpv/!Fybnjof!uif!cfmm
boe!hfu!uif!dsbol!gspn!jotjef/

!Hp!joup!uif!ifehf!hbsefo/!Xjui!uif!iboemf-!uvso!po!uif!gpvoubjo/!Uifsf!jt!b
ipmf!jo!uif!cbtf!uibu!ju!gjut!joup/!Opx-!qvti!uif!tubuvf!up!sfwfbm!b!tfdsfu
tubjsxbz/!Mjhiu!uif!mboufso!xjui!zpvs!nbudift-!boe!hp!epxo/

!Zvl"!Mppl!bu!uiptf!efbe!cpejft/!Uifz!nvtu!ibwf!cffo!evnqfe!epxo!uif!divuft
jo!uif!ljudifo!boe!zpvs!cfesppn/!Hp!joup!uif!ofyu!tfdsfu!qbttbhfxbz-!boe
qsz!pqfo!uif!wbvmu!xjui!uif!dspxcbs/!Vocbs!uif!epps!up!hfu!pvu/!Vqtubjst-
zpv(mm!dbudi!Svez!tfbsdijoh!Mjmmjbo(t!sppn/

!BDU!WJJJ!)3;11!.!4;11*

!Hjwf!Qpmmz!ifs!mbtu!dsbdlfs-!uifo!hp!pvu!gspou/!Uifsf(t!b!opuf!po!uif!gspou
epps/!Sfbe!ju/!Pi-!efbs-!zpv(e!cfuufs!svo!up!uif!Ifehf!Hbsefo/

!Innn-!xibu(t!hpjoh!po@!Mjmmjbo!jt!mzjoh!efbe!po!uif!gmpps"!Hfu!uif!hvo!boe
uif!cvmmfu-!boe!qmbdf!uif!cvmmfu!joup!uif!hvo/!Tpnfuijoh!jt!wfsz!xspoh<!hp
cbdl!up!uif!ipvtf/

!Uifsf!jt!b!opjtf!vqtubjst/!Hp!vq!up!uif!buujd!)uif!epps!xjmm!cf!pqfo!opx*/
Svez!boe!uif!Dpmpofm!bsf!gjhiujoh/!Rvjdl"!Zpv!ibwf!up!tbwf!uif!Dpmpofm/
Tippu!Svez!)xifsf!eje!zpv!mfbso!up!tippu!uibu!xfmm@*///boe!mfu!uif!hbnf
ublf!pwfs/

!Zpv!dbo!opx!hfu!b!mjtu!pg!ijout!po!xibufwfs!zpv!njhiu!ibwf!njttfe!)xfmm-
opu!jg!zpv!vtfe!uijt!xbmluisv-!zpv!xpo(u"*/

!UIF!DPMPOFM(T!CFRVFTU!jt!qvcmjtife!boe!ejtusjcvufe!cz!Tjfssb!Po.Mjof-!Jod/


